Effectiveness of Laryngeal Electrotherapy on Voice and Self-Perception in Women With Hyperfunctional Dysphonia


Objective: To evaluate the effectiveness of laryngeal electrotherapy with low-frequency TENS, applied simultaneously with vocal exercises, and to compare its effects with isolated TENS on vocal quality and self-perception of easy and clear voice in women with hyperfunctional dysphonia.

Methodology: Cross-sectional study, Ethics Committee (approval 4.022.860). Twenty-two women (mean age 31.0 ± 7.27) with hyperfunctional dysphonia participated of this study. They were divided into two groups: ELVE (11 women) received TENS+vocal exercises, and EL (11 women) received only electrotherapy with TENS. TENS was applied with electrodes on the thyroid cartilage bilaterally (10Hz, 200_s phase, motor threshold at low intensity). All participants underwent 12 sessions, twice a week, with an initial 5-minute orientation on vocal hygiene. Recordings of sustained vowel /a/ and counting were made before and after intervention. Perceptual-auditory analysis of vocal quality (overall grade, breathiness, and tension), multiparametric measures (Acoustic Voice Quality Index [AVQI] and Breathiness Index [ABI]), and self-perception of “easy voice” and “clear voice” (10 cm visual analog scale) were conducted. To compare effects before/after intervention and between groups, paired T-test, Wilcoxon, and independent samples T-test were applied (p<0.05). Effect size analysis was conducted using Cohen's d (d=0.2 to 0.4=small effect; d=0.5 to 0.7=medium effect; and d=0.8 or greater=large effect.

Results: There was no significant difference in perceptual-auditory analysis after the intervention and between groups. Effect size on vocal quality was small (d0.5) after intervention. Improvement in self-perception of “easy voice” and “clear voice” was found only in the EL group (p=0.021 and p=0.005, respectively), with a large effect (r__=-1.00).

Conclusion: The isolated application of low-frequency TENS in women with hyperfunctional dysphonia resulted in a reduction of ABI values, indicating a significant improvement in the degree of breathiness. Similarly, there was improvement in self-perception of “easy voice” and “clear voice,” an effect not observed with TENS combined with vocal exercises.

Kelly
Stephano
Leticia
Daniela
Alcione
Larissa
Leonardo
Silverio
Varela
Bonini
Hencke
Brasolotto
Siqueira
Lopes